What You Sleep On
Pillow for Side Sleepers vs Back Sleepers: Which Height?
Side sleepers need the tallest pillow, back sleepers a medium one and stomach sleepers the thinnest, because the gap between your head and the mattress changes with the way you lie. Lying on your side, your shoulder holds your head up, so the pillow fills the space between your ear and the bed. A back sleeper's pillow fills the hollow under the neck and stays lower under the head. A stomach sleeper's head is turned and already close to the mattress, so a very thin pillow or a few handfuls of fill keeps the neck closest to level.
This episode came out of a post on our blog.
Full transcript
Circadian: Lie on your side tonight and notice where your head goes. If it tips down toward the mattress, your pillow's too low. If it's pushed up toward the ceiling, it's too high. Side sleepers need the tallest pillow, back sleepers a medium one, and stomach sleepers the thinnest, because the gap under your head changes with the way you lie. We sell pillows, so weigh what we say, but none of that part is about us. On your side, your shoulder holds your whole upper body off the mattress.
Circadian: So there's a gap between your ear and the bed, and it gets wider the broader your shoulders are, and the pillow's only job is to fill it so your head rests level with the rest of you. Too little, and your head drops. Too much, and it gets shoved up. Either way, your neck spends the night bent. On your back, the gap is smaller, and most of it sits under your neck instead of your head. So a back pillow fills the hollow under your neck and stays lower under your head, which means you end up resting with your face pointed straight at the ceiling instead of tipped forward or back.
Circadian: Too high pushes your chin toward your chest. Too low lets your head tip back. And on your stomach? Your head's turned to one side, and it's already close to the mattress. So the less you put under it, the closer your neck stays to level, and that's why stomach sleepers do best on a very thin pillow, or only a few handfuls of fill. This is where you'd expect a number, right? Most pillows are sold at one fixed height. Someone else picked it. But a team of researchers went back through the studies on pillow height published since nineteen ninety-seven, about twenty-four years of work, looking at neck alignment, body size, pressure on the head and shoulder, and how hard the neck muscles work.
Circadian: They found there still aren't any firm conclusions about the best height, for back sleepers or for side sleepers. Twenty-four years. No number. It sounds like a failure, doesn't it, until you see what a small later study found. It looked at side sleepers on pillows of different heights, and the height that kept each neck closest to its natural curve tracked that person's shoulder width. So a broad-shouldered man and a narrow-shouldered woman, both lying on their sides in the same bed, need different pillows, even if a store would sell them the exact same one on the same day.
Circadian: Why does that matter? In our opinion, it's the best reason a single fixed height can't be right for everybody. Someone wrote to us about this. She sleeps on her side, then her back, then her stomach, all in one night. On her stomach she couldn't get comfortable, because her buckwheat pillow felt too hard. So she started stacking a down pillow on top of it. Two pillows stacked is a lot of height under a turned head. On her side, two pillows might be fine, if her shoulders are broad.
Circadian: On her stomach, that much height bends her neck back. So pick one pillow, and set it for the position you're in for most of the night. If that's your side, keep it fuller. If your stomach's the hard part, a softer fill gives way when your head turns. Fair enough, who knows how they're lying while they're asleep? But the position you wake up in is a decent guess. Side sleepers need a fill that holds its height through the night. Buckwheat's the firmest we make, and you can pour more in through the zipper to build it up for broad shoulders without it going soft.
Circadian: Shredded latex is springier, so it cushions your ear and cheek while it holds your neck up. And cotton works for side sleepers if you keep it packed full, because the fiber is dense. Back sleepers do well on buckwheat too, since it molds to the curve of the neck and then stays put. And stomach sleepers? Buckwheat's usually too firm and too tall for them. Kapok suits them better, because it's soft and sits low to medium. And if you sleep on your side but love how kapok feels, leave extra fill in, or go with buckwheat or cotton when you want it really firm.
Circadian: Every Circadian pillow arrives full, with about thirty percent more fill than most people end up keeping, and a zipper down the side. So you open it, take fill out a handful at a time until it fits the way you sleep, and keep the extra in a bag in the closet for the day the pillow settles and you want some of that height back. Side sleepers keep the most. Back sleepers take some out. Stomach sleepers take out the most. That's our answer to the missing number: you set the height for your own shoulders.
Circadian: It does take a few nights of adjusting. And some people would rather open a box and go to sleep, and that's fair. Will a pillow you've set perfectly stay that way? Not forever. Kapok settles a little lower over months, and a quick shake each morning brings most of the height back. Wool settles slowly too, so you lower it by lifting the outermost layer off from the outside, and when you want it higher again, you lay that same layer back in where it was.
Circadian: Cotton compresses over the years, and that's why the zipper matters, since you can add fill back in. And buckwheat feels firm the first few nights, so give your neck about three to seven nights before you decide it's wrong. Lie on your side on your own pillow, and prop your phone up on the nightstand. Take one photo from the foot of the bed. Then look at your neck. Is it level? It should carry straight on from your upper back. Head tipped down, put some fill back in.
Circadian: Head pushed up, take a handful out and take another photo. So how do you sleep: side, back, stomach, or all three in one night?
This episode is narrated by synthetic voices. The words are ours.